Charlie Brown Music Videos: Which do you prefer?

[42JTR]

Do you prefer the studio version Music video or de live Music video?

For everyone who doesn't like the studio version video here's the live video with the music from the studio version (link removed) Enjoy! For link PM me!

STUDIO:

Coldplay - Charlie Brown - YouTube

LIVE:

Coldplay - Charlie Brown (Live) - YouTube

[hps]

Studio version = 1/10

Live version = 9/10

[juanif94]

Live version

[Prospector]

I love both, but the studio is better :)

[InvaderXyl42]

Live version wins by a landslide for me. There are so many things they could have done to the studio version to make it better :shame:

[jeremyy]

live version. i can watch it over and over again.!

[Magnolia]

For me the live version is way better.
This studio version video started out well and had real potential but went bad so fast.

[filiprasmusson]

Studio, waaay better in my opinion ;)

[The Red Army]

If someone could dub the studio version of the song to the live music video, then we would have the perfect CB video.

[42JTR]

If someone could dub the studio version of the song to the live music video, then we would have the perfect CB video.

I made one but it won't show on youtube due to breach in copyright:(

[The Red Army]

I made one but it won't show on youtube due to breach in copyright:(


ooo man...could you upload it to rapidshare or mediafire...by any chance

or a lot of these videos on youtube use mirror images so they won't get breached by copyright (maybe that would work...)

[42JTR]

ooo man...could you upload it to rapidshare or mediafire...by any chance

or a lot of these videos on youtube use mirror images so they won't get breached by copyright (maybe that would work...)

I'm working on it I'll post the link when it's uploaded. I'm also gonna try and mirror the video maybe it will work then.

[m@r@]

Live version !!

[The Red Army]

Thanks for the link, downloading now

[Denise]

Live hands down

[JosephRengifo]

Just like the Lost! video, the live video for Charlie Brown is amazing. The studio version wasn't really necessary, in my opinion.

[vanessarrent]

Live version !!!!!

[jomarr]

Studio is very magical, I prefer this. I love the live version too.

[anitarita]

Live is so much richer in sound. The noise of the croud just adds another dimension that can never be duplicated in the studio.

[Blue Nails]

Prefer the live one too. The memories! :dazzled:

[Raphaele]

live!

[macky]

STUDIO

[filiprasmusson]

Studio, easy, easy. soo easy. (Chris Martin on Extras :D)

[laga]

Live version

[Estefaniapc]

Studio version <3

[hps]

Fast pool by Coldplace.eu :

http://desmond.imageshack.us/Himg29/scaled.php?server=29&filename=123mmo.jpg&res=medium

So, Live Version win!

[Coldplay3277]

Studio Version. Shit.

Live FTW.

[roz42]

live version deffo!!!

[Glastra]

Live version fo' sho!

[hammysammy-mx]

I love the live version!! But i dont hate the studio version

[shred]

Hmm I can't decide now. The studio version is definitely growing on me.

The the theme of the studio one fits with the song really well but then the live version shows the energy of the song and the full effects of the Xylotobands better than the studio one did. So I don't know...

Can I vote for both?! :P

[ilovechriss]

Live :nod:

[Kiame]

It's funny, I think the Live music video captures the themes expressed in the studio one but does it even better.

So yeah, I really don't see the point in the studio video. I was hoping they'd do something a little more out there.

[MariamLeto]

Live version

[novocaine89]

I prefer live version because I always fall for live performances so helplessly, especially when it comes to Glastonbury Festival!

[Arantza]

Live, there's no doubt.